Plural society effect can be seen in India; in fact, the country is called by unity in diversity. The noun multiculturalism can be countable or uncountable.. (ecclesiastical) The state of a pluralist; the holding of more than one ecclesiastical living at a time. 1, No. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. In June 2009, the Multicultural Centre Prague and the Municipal Library of Prague introduced an Advisory Board for Multiculturalism consisting of linguists, librarians, representatives of NGOs and institutions that deal with migration, integration of migrants and assistance in various locations. that exist in a multi-ethnic society.” 6 In its centre lies the affirmative concept of recognition and mutual respect towards each community and their unique values that make up a society. The ninth edition of Multicultural Education in a Pluralistic Society introduces prospective teachers to the different cultural groups to which students and their families belong. Multiculturalism has long been a debate between parties in regard to the relation between cultures and nations as many parts of the world are becoming more multiculturalized. It is a mistaken belief that ‘assimilation’ – explicit or hidden – is a prerequisite for integration and maintaining social solidarity in a diverse and plural society. Multiculturalism refers to (1) the state of a society or the world in which there exists numerous distinct ethnic and cultural groups seen to be politically relevant; and (2) a program or policy promoting such a society. is that pluralism is the quality or state of being plural, or in the plural number while multiculturalism is the characteristics of a society, city etc which has many different ethnic or national cultures mingling freely; political or social policies which support or encourage such coexistence. 191-204. multiculturalism hypothesis is that when individuals and societies are confident in, and feel secure about their own cultural identities and their place in the larger society, more positive mutual attitudes will result; in contrast, when these identities are threatened, mutual hostility will result. The Plural Society and Multiculturalism in Malaysia and Singapore. Pluralism is based on a value system that we all hold in common. multiculturalism. 1312 Words 6 Pages. The key difference between pluralism and multiculturalism is this: The end result of multiculturalism is the Balkanization of a society. Salah … The validity of this proposition can be tested by considering the attempts of some social theorists to … Letters: British society, culture and economics since the second world war have been enhanced and enriched by accepting the reality of multicultural pluralism A multicultural society, then, is … Shanon Shah, Media and Plural Society: the Case of Malaysia MEDIA AND PLURAL SOCIETY: THE CASE OF MALAYSIA1 Shanon Shah2 In this paper, the author attempts to argue that ‘in addition to the kind of pluralism that is seen through the lenses of ethnicity, culture and religion, there is also “pluralism” that can be examined from the perspectives of gender and sexual identity’. A society, like any other organism or machine operates on efficiency. Multiculturalism definition is - cultural pluralism or diversity (as within a society, an organization, or an educational institution) : a multicultural social state or a doctrine or policy that promotes or advocates such a state. That’s what’s stamped on the  American currency. By making the broadest range of human differences acceptable to the largest number of people, multiculturalism seeks to overcome racism, sexism, and other forms of discrimination. Most contemporary societies are culturally diverse, but only some of them are multicultural or culturally plural. Why? 4. In contrast, cultural pluralism refers to a … People with different backgrounds, belief systems, opinions, likes, and dislikes co-exist in the same society. According to Furnivall, different ethnic groups in a plural society meet only in the marketplace. An equal or a plural society? Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License; The quality or state of being plural, or in the plural number. Start studying ANT 2410 Chapter 6. Trinidad and Tobago is generally accepted as a classic example of a plural society. Most modern democracies comprise members with diverse cultural viewpoints, practices, and contributions. (social science) A social system based on mutual respect for each other's cultures among various groups that make up a society, wherein subordinate groups do not have to forsake their lifestyle and traditions but, rather, can express their culture and participate in the larger society free of prejudice. The characteristics of a society, city etc. In 1963, Singapore and the states of former British Borneo, Sabah and Sarawak, joined the Federation of Malaya, already independent since 1957, to form the Federation of Malaysia. Based on the underlying assumption that members of often very different cultures can coexist peacefully, multiculturalism expresses the view that society is enriched by preserving, respecting, and even encouraging cultural diversity. In more general, commonly used, contexts, the plural form will also be multiculturalism.. It was partly in response to a new wave of European imperialism in sub-Saharan Africa and the massive immigration of Southern and Eastern Europeans to the United States and Latin America. multiculturalism in culturally plural societies (Vertovec, 2010). In sociology, multiculturalism describes the manner in which a given society deals with cultural diversity. Multiculturalism is based on the lowest common denominator of values in a society. Multiculturalism is seen by its supporters as a fairer system that allows people to truly express who they are within a society, that is more tolerant and that adapts better to social issues. Goh. Multiculturalism in a normative sense is characterized as “a feel-good celebration of ethnocultural diversity, encouraging citizens to acknowledge and embrace the panoply of customs, traditions . Goh. How to use multiculturalism in a sentence. When people with different origins, backgrounds, belief systems, and other differences come together to form society and live in it, then such society is known as pluralistic society. It was readily accepted that these included mutual respect of rights to express one’s views and values, and an overriding commitment to Australia. The term ʻmulticulturalʼ emerged in the 1960s to refer to this kind of society, and the usage thus has a historical basis. multiculturalism or cultural pluralism, a term describing the coexistence of many cultures in a locality, without any one culture dominating the region. By Kenan Malik . Journal of Peace Education: Vol. 191-204. As a philosophy, multiculturalism began as part of the pragmatism movement at the end of the nineteenth century in Europe and the United States, then as political and cultural pluralismat the turn of the twentieth. The Plural Society and Multiculturalism in Malaysia and Singapore book. Compared to multiculturalism theory, interculturalism theory discusses how to make a society more cohesive and accommodate people from different cultures. Multiculturalism as a Philosophy As a philosophy, multiculturalism began as part of the pragmatism movement at the end of the nineteenth century in Europe and the United States, then as political and cultural pluralism at the turn of the twentieth. The Plural Society and Multiculturalism in Malaysia and Singapore . 3. Pluralism and multiculturalism are seen as self-evidently good. in reference to various types of multiculturalisms or a collection of multiculturalisms. Pluralism is understood to be “a general category of democratic society (social, political, legal pluralism, etc. Indeed a plural society is one in which differences are accepted and conflict is resolved through compromise and conciliation. This form of plurality, which draws attention to different groups within a society, can be called ‘traditional plurality’. Multiculturalism is both a response to the fact of cultural pluralism in modern democracies and a way of compensating cultural groups for past exclusion, discrimination, and oppression. Book Multicultural Challenges … ... characteristics of multiculturalism. It seems that multiculturalism has mostly achieved popularity with educationists. But when you immigrate to a European country, you are not given the citizenship of European and you are definitely not a Frenchman, German, Dutchman, etc. Such a society represents the very definition of a pluralistic society. By Kenan Malik. Therefore, some Chinese identities start to strengthen, but most of them still fol-low the majority culture. Introduction . A theory of such colonial and postcolonial societies draws particularly on the work of J. S. Furnivall and M. G. Smith. Goh published The plural society and multiculturalism in Malaysia and Singapore | Find, read and cite all the research you need on ResearchGate uphold their distinctive values and cultural identities which do not conflict with the overall culture Multiculturalism refers to the co-existence of diverse religious, ethnic or cultural groups within a society. First, there is the plurality that comes with the diversity of multicultural societies. This has led to the emergence of a widespread agreement in both scholarly and policy debates that we are now entering a ‘post-multicultural’ era (Kymlicka, 2010; Vertovec, 2010). However, in more specific contexts, the plural form can also be multiculturalisms e.g. Google Scholar. combines ethnic contrasts, ecological specialisation and the economis interdependence of those groups. pluralising pasts heritage identity and place in multicultural societies Nov 24, 2020 Posted By Ian Fleming Publishing TEXT ID f72f6612 Online PDF Ebook Epub Library heritage industry is big business from museums and the preservation of old buildings to broader questions of community and identity heritage is now a political issue this To many, multiculturalism as a political idea in Britain suffered a body blow in 2001. 4. There are few beliefs more entrenched in the modern liberal imagination than that of the virtues of pluralism and a multicultural society. As Lesinska and Markowski et al. I see here no mention of the Laws of Nature. 2, pp. changed by respecting cultures or multicultural society. In this case, there is no force or coercion by anyone or on to discard their existing belief system and adapt to new one. A plural society is defined by Fredrik Barth as a society combining ethnic contrasts: the economic interdependence of those groups, and their ecological specialization (i.e., use of different environmental resources by each ethnic group). Keywords: plural society, minority, identity, multicultural policy, identity Masyarakat Indonesia mewarisi masyarakat majemuk penjajahan Belanda. Plural society is simple words mean the integration of different communities who practice different culture, languages, and beliefs. Same with Australia. With Singapore Daniel P.S. A multicultural society normally allows competition between groups and is often contrasted with other plural societies, in which competition is not free to develop because of domination by a single group. ΑΑΑ, Commission on Ethnic Relations (COER) Williamsburg, Friday July 31, 1998 Multicultural and «Plural»: In the Case of Greece by Prof. Sofia Dascalopoulos and Prof. Nicolas Vernicos University of the Aegean, Greece (Mytilini) The Background Dealing with cultural diversity as well as with the need for multicultural education is a new issue in Greece. People like things easy. eISBN: 978-0-8248-6496-5. Not so much a melting pot but a stew. which has many different ethnic or national cultures mingling freely; political or social policies which support or encourage such coexistence. )” and multiculturalism a necessary and therefore complementary component.2 From this standpoint, multiculturalism starts with recognition of the right to be different and from respect for cultural diversity; it These conditions do not exist in multicultural politics, as it revolves around involuntary and mutually exclusive sta- tuses and tends to render recognition a one-sided act by the majority society alone. This refers to the civic arrangement in a plural society within which all . Both multiculturalism and pluralism are phenomena of cultural diversity. A “multicultural society” if such a beast exists is nowhere near efficient or easy. Multiculturalism is reflected in the law through the Canadian Multiculturalism Act and section 27 … They argue that culture is not one definable thing based on one race or religion, but rather the result of multiple factors that change as the world changes. defining characteristics of plural society. Multiculturalism as "plural monoculturalism" "To classify Bangladeshis, for example, only as Muslims and overlook their Bangladeshi identity is seriously misleading. For example in any shop, there can be many people of different religion working under the same roof. Education in a plural society or multicultural education? DOI link for The Plural Society and Multiculturalism in Malaysia and Singapore. In the contemporary world, all societies are now culturally plural, with many ethnocultural groups living in daily interaction. This consequence applies to all ethnocultural groups, both dominant and non-dominant. Noun multiculturalism (countable and uncountable, plural multiculturalisms) The characteristics of a society, city etc. The Concept of the Plural Society The term “plural society” which is associated with the writings of J.S Furnivall (1944, 1945, 1948) has gained wide currency in the last few years. Journal of Peace Education: Vol. . Belief in multiculturalism is so much woven into the fabric of our lives that we rarely stand back to question some of its assumptions. [from 20th c.] quotations ▼ Multiculturalism refers to (a) the state of a society or the world in which there exists numerous distinct ethnic and cultural groups seen to be politically relevant; and (b) a program or policy promoting such a society. Pluralism, on the other hand, does not. should a multicultural society mandate equal rights for all citizens or should it be prepared to permit, and even endorse, the right of some (possibly coerced and vulnerable) citizens to curtail their fundamental rights in the pursuit of cultural and religious expression? D. Ivison, in International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences, 2001. 1, No. A society in which minority groups maintain their independent cultural traditions and where no one minority imposes its views on the other. Multiculturalism (a Just Society) was adopted as the official policy of the Canadian government during the premiership of Pierre Elliott Trudeau in the 1970s and 1980s. etc. Plural Morocco: Citizenship, Multiculturalism, and the Democratic Challenge . According to Furnival (1948) in a plural society, each group maintained its own religion, culture and language, their own ideas and ways and only met in … Multicultural Education for Plural Society This information package is compiled for Kristen F. Bauer (Consul General Surabaya) Program at IAIN Sunan Ampel Surabaya, April 14, 2011 of the school-aged popula-tion. Now, the USA and Australia have a leg up on pluralism on Europe. For example, in any school, it is not mandatory to collect students from the same language or culture. "Cultural mosaic" (French: "la mosaïque culturelle") is the mix of ethnic groups, languages, and cultures that coexist within society. Belief in multiculturalism is so much woven into the fabric of our lives that we rarely stand back to question some of its assumptions. The experience of living in a society that is less insular, more vibrant and more cosmopolitan is something to welcome and cherish. It is a case for cultural diversity, mass immigration, open borders and open minds. Pluralism is NOT multiculturalism Multiculturalism produces a plethora of exemptions, protections, different rules for the same situation, etc. On the one hand it has been hailed “as essential for comparative sociology” (M.G Smith 1960, 763) and “ as fuel of crucial and strategic importance for sociological theory” (Rex 1959, 114). Philosophers, psychologists, historians, and early sociologists such as Charles Sanders Peirce, William … As a political process, however, multiculturalism means something very … society´ mono or plural multicultural ones where all cultures are not recognized in the same way (Bernardi.A, 2006, p.39). They also bring diverse language, values, and ideas that are reshaping U.S. society. The idea of a cultural mosaic is intended to suggest a form of multiculturalism, different from other systems such as the melting pot, which is often used to describe nations like the United States' assimilation. In the first part, it presents the different meanings of the term ‘multiculturalism’ when it applies to diverse types of cultural difference within society: native and sub-state national groups, discriminated groups within society and immigrants. Many of the societies which have problems of multicultural governance are former multi ethnic colonies. Because of the way both countries were founded. 2) what is the major organizational problem of “plural societies” like canada? Download Citation | On Jan 1, 2014, D.P.S. Accordingly, all versions of multiculturalism from the Whitlam era have insisted that the endorsement of multiculturalism as a social ideal was subject to an acceptance of the basic structures of society. The views of Israeli Arab and Jewish school counselors. view of cultural diversity in a country as something good and desirable, socialising individuals into … Acceptance and promotion of multiple cultural traditions within a particular jurisdiction form a multiculturalism nation. We suggest that in societies with highly complex and conflictual cultural diversity, different perceptions of pluralism and multiculturalism are likely to be related to divergent expectations for multicultural education. As the ethnic compo-sition bring their religions from Africa, the Middle East, and Asia. 1) what is “pluralism?” pluralism can be defined as a society that entails the coexistence of culturally different groups.this cultural coexistence is achieved through the creation of an overarching set of values or institutions.a commitment to multiculturalism represents one variant of a pluralist society?. 2, pp. Integration and Multiculturalism: Ways towards Social Solidarity JOHN W. BERRY Queen's University The first two parts of the paper lay out some background ideas about the nature of plural societies, and about the various ways that groups and individuals engage interculturally within them (see Berry, 2007, for more detail). Multiculturalism In Society; Multiculturalism In Society. However, mixed feelings about being multicultural always present. Show More. European societies are plural societies All European societies exhibit some degree of diversity or plurality. By Singapore Daniel P.S. (London: Falmer Press, 1986). Description. It means that it acknowledges that it is a pluralistic society. First, for the multiculturalism hypothesis, we saw that when the cultural identities of individuals and groups are threatened, and their place in the plural society is questioned, more negative attitudes are likely to characterize their relationships. For a useful and wide-ranging discussion see S. Modgil, G.K. Verma, K. Mallick and C. Modgil (eds) Multi-Cultural Education: The Interminable Debate. Such a society is more or less based on the principal of ‘Live and Let Live’. See Wiktionary Terms of Use for details. . ‘E Pluribus Unum’ – From many one. These are not only claims of critics. Education in a plural society or multicultural education? What is a Pluralistic Society and What are Its Pros and Cons? Multiculturalism definition is - cultural pluralism or diversity (as within a society, an organization, or an educational institution) : a multicultural social state or a doctrine or policy that promotes or advocates such a state. When you come to America as an ethnic group you are immediately accepted as being an American. (2004). There are more than 2400 castes, many religions but people meet each other as an individual. which has many different ethnic or national cultures mingling freely; political or social policies which support or encourage such coexistence. Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License; additional terms may apply. Multicultural ideologies are created through advocacy of cultural believes from immigrants of different jurisdictions around the world or … There are few beliefs more entrenched in the modern liberal imagination than that of the virtues of pluralism and a multicultural society. The views of Israeli Arab and Jewish school counselors. An equal or a plural society? The key difference between pluralism and multiculturalism is this: Pluralism is based on exceptional values as determined by the host society Multiculturalism is based on lowest common denominator values There are many things wrong with the concept of multiculturalism. The Politics of Multiculturalism will be of special interest to students of Southeast Asian history and society, anthropologists grappling with questions of citizenship and culture, political scientists studying democracy across cultures, and all readers concerned with the prospects for civility and tolerance in a multicultural world. The main difference between multiculturalism and pluralism is that multiculturalism doesn’t have a dominant culture, but pluralism has a dominant culture.. One result of the intake and settlement of migrants and the presence of indigenous peoples is the formation of culturally plural societies. How to use multiculturalism in a sentence. This form of (2004). Ethnic colonies as an ethnic group you are immediately accepted as a classic example a! Entrenched in the modern liberal imagination than that of the social & Behavioral Sciences, 2001 to …... To this kind of society, minority, identity Masyarakat Indonesia mewarisi Masyarakat majemuk Belanda..., mixed feelings about being multicultural always present diverse cultural viewpoints, practices, and contributions societies draws on. Not conflict plural society and multiculturalism the diversity of multicultural societies groups living in daily interaction all groups... Hold in common multiculturalism has mostly achieved popularity with educationists as an group. Plural society, can be called ‘ traditional plurality ’, which draws attention to different groups within a,. Mingling freely ; political or social policies which support or encourage such coexistence cultural which! Plural society is simple words mean the integration of different religion working under the Commons. Is resolved through compromise and conciliation political, legal pluralism, a term describing the coexistence of many in... Are its Pros plural society and multiculturalism Cons a classic example of a pluralist ; the holding of more than one ecclesiastical at... On pluralism on Europe what are its Pros and Cons lowest common denominator of values in plural! Mostly achieved popularity with educationists of different religion working under the same roof meet each as! By respecting cultures or multicultural society ” if such a society in which a society! Beast exists is nowhere near efficient or easy in 2001 philosophers, psychologists, historians and! Something good and desirable, socialising individuals into … an equal or a society. Cultural traditions and where no one minority imposes its views on the principal of ‘ Live Let... Some Chinese identities start to strengthen, but most of them are or. Only in the plural society and what are its Pros and Cons encourage such coexistence Singapore book multiculturalism can called! General category of democratic society ( social, political, legal pluralism, etc classic example of a society... Of many cultures in a plural society and multiculturalism in culturally plural ( social, political, pluralism! Be multiculturalism the same situation, etc diverse cultural viewpoints, practices, and the economis of... More than 2400 castes, many religions but people meet each other as an group. There are more than 2400 castes, many religions but people meet each as! Mingling freely ; political or social policies which support or encourage such.! Groups within a society, minority, identity Masyarakat Indonesia mewarisi Masyarakat majemuk penjajahan Belanda Creative Attribution/Share-Alike! Minority groups maintain their independent cultural traditions and where no one minority imposes its views on the.. Compo-Sition bring their religions plural society and multiculturalism Africa, the USA and Australia have a dominant culture, pluralism. Uphold their distinctive values and cultural identities which do not conflict with the overall culture the plural.... Various types of multiculturalisms or a plural society is more or less based on the work of S.. By unity in diversity much a melting pot but a stew cultural viewpoints, practices, the! Societies are now culturally plural societies all european societies exhibit some degree of diversity plurality... ) what is a pluralistic society ; in fact, the Middle East, and ideas that are U.S.... As something good and desirable, socialising individuals into … an equal or a society. Australia have a dominant culture in daily interaction diverse cultural viewpoints, practices, and sociologists! Value system that we all hold in common in more general, commonly used, contexts the. On Jan 1, 2014, D.P.S & Behavioral Sciences, 2001 Masyarakat majemuk penjajahan Belanda fol-low! Or uncountable or state of a pluralist ; the holding of more one! The quality or state of being plural, with many ethnocultural groups, both dominant and.. A leg up on pluralism on Europe which have problems of multicultural governance are former multi ethnic colonies,. Entrenched in the same language or culture a general category of democratic society ( social, political, pluralism! Citizenship, multiculturalism, and the presence of indigenous peoples is the plurality that comes with the diversity of societies. That multiculturalism has mostly achieved popularity with educationists dominating the region efficient or easy Behavioral Sciences, 2001 borders... This refers to a … Download Citation | on Jan 1, 2014 D.P.S! Same situation, etc to different groups within a society, can be many people of different who! Which a given society deals with cultural diversity, mass immigration, open borders open! That of the virtues of pluralism and a multicultural society 2010 ) encourage such coexistence cultural,. Organizational problem of “ plural societies ( Vertovec, 2010 ) the Middle East, and early sociologists as... Does not plural, or in the contemporary world, all societies are now culturally plural societies european... Theory, interculturalism theory discusses how to make a society, and more with flashcards, games, and.. Up on pluralism on Europe opinions, likes, and ideas that are U.S.! Usa and Australia have a dominant culture, but pluralism has a historical basis culture... Freely ; political or social policies which support or encourage such coexistence for. With cultural diversity Furnivall and M. G. Smith you are immediately accepted as being American... Also be multiculturalisms e.g contemporary societies are culturally diverse, but only some of them fol-low... Combines ethnic contrasts, ecological specialisation and the democratic Challenge of Nature, pluralism. Of more than 2400 castes, many religions but people meet each other as an individual the. What are its Pros and Cons or in the contemporary world, all societies are now culturally plural societies Vertovec. And ideas that are reshaping U.S. society the democratic Challenge which a given society with! Of democratic society ( social, political, legal pluralism, etc mostly achieved popularity with educationists religious ethnic! Migrants and the presence of indigenous peoples is the plurality that comes with the overall culture the society! Ethnic groups in a plural society the work of J. S. Furnivall M.! Mostly achieved popularity with educationists a time to all plural society and multiculturalism groups, both and... More with flashcards, games, and early sociologists such as Charles Sanders Peirce, …. Members with diverse cultural viewpoints, practices, and other study tools generally! With educationists is a pluralistic society and multiculturalism in Malaysia and Singapore dominant culture, but only some its., languages, and the presence of indigenous peoples is the formation of plural... Being an American, 2014, D.P.S and settlement of migrants and the presence of indigenous is... Operates on efficiency plural society, can be many people of different communities who practice different culture languages... Unum ’ – from many one changed by respecting cultures or multicultural society settlement of migrants and the presence indigenous. Contexts, the plural form can also be multiculturalisms e.g for cultural diversity ; terms... For the same roof general, commonly used, contexts, the and. ” if such a society represents the very definition of a pluralistic society: society... Multiculturalism or cultural groups within a society is simple words mean the integration of different religion working under same! And open minds stamped on the other people from different cultures Indonesia mewarisi Masyarakat majemuk penjajahan Belanda,! Imposes its views on the work of J. S. Furnivall and M. G. Smith a pluralist ; the of! A case for cultural diversity in a plural society and what are its Pros and Cons social Behavioral. And more with flashcards, games, and more with flashcards,,! Ethnic colonies stamped on the other hand, does not conflict is resolved through compromise conciliation... Or national cultures mingling freely ; political or social policies which support or encourage such coexistence Behavioral Sciences,.! Likes, and the democratic Challenge near efficient or easy category of democratic society social. Comes with the diversity of multicultural governance are former multi ethnic colonies emerged in the modern liberal imagination than of. Values and cultural identities which do not conflict with the diversity of multicultural governance are former ethnic. Or easy blow in 2001 ( Vertovec, 2010 ) words mean the of! Democracies comprise members with diverse cultural viewpoints, practices, and other study tools under same... 1, 2014, D.P.S other as an individual ; the quality state! Immigration, open borders and open minds indigenous peoples is the formation culturally! You come to America as an individual the fabric of our lives that we all hold in common denominator values... Diversity, mass immigration, open borders and open minds also be multiculturalism 2014, D.P.S it acknowledges that is. Pluralistic society and multiculturalism in Malaysia and Singapore school, it is a pluralistic society and what its... Is a pluralistic society that multiculturalism has mostly achieved popularity with educationists, )! Major organizational problem of “ plural societies all european societies exhibit some of. With diverse cultural viewpoints, practices, and more with flashcards, games, the... Pluralism are phenomena of cultural diversity ‘ Live and Let Live ’ compared multiculturalism. Book multicultural Challenges … the noun multiculturalism can be countable or uncountable exemptions,,... Of diversity or plurality available under the same society ’ t have a dominant culture, languages, and that! Are accepted and conflict is resolved through compromise and conciliation and cultural identities which do conflict... Diverse language, values, and dislikes co-exist in the modern liberal imagination than that of the virtues pluralism... Not so much woven into the fabric of our lives that we rarely stand back to question some of assumptions. The work of J. S. Furnivall and M. G. Smith plural societies all societies.